Cutting the Cord : Switching to Internet Only

This part is two fold. First its the experience of actually telling Xfinity that I was done.  This wasn’t too bad but just stick to your guns.  I could not do it online and had to call them and she tried to figure out what other packages I could use, even acting shocked when I said we had never picked up the land line we used to have but only had it because it was cheaper with a triple play than with a double play.  Once we got past the part where I constantly turned down the extra offers we got to the point of figuring out what internet only plan I wanted.  My current plan was for 200 mbps, which for most people was probably fine but was going to be about $80 a month anyway.  I asked what they had better, after I had already researched online but I gave her a shot.  She claimed she could only do a 400 mbps or a 600 mbps.  I politely inquired about a gigabit service I had heard about, “oh well we could do that but you would need a new cable modem/router” Since I spend the $10 fee every month to rent the router from Xfinity this seemed like something that should not have been an issue.  I spoke with her a little longer and found out that gigabit to my house was $115 a month.  Since I have all my smart home components plus we planned to only stream this seemed like a no brainer. It did require them to come install it which was more so they could configure it to the house but that was actually handy because I could turn in all my old cable boxes to the technician and didnt have to ship them.

Everything was going well with the install but after a day or two of testing I found my Ubiquiti AC-LR access points could just not handle the speed well for me and needed an upgrade.  I have been a big fan of the Ubiquiti gear but it is expensive, this was when i found the Google Wifi mesh network.  For $249 for a 3 pack on Amazon I figured I would try them and worse case return them.  I was very happy with them.  The install took less than 15 minutes and they are tucked away and hardly noticeable.

I did add the CloverTale outlet wall mount that was $10 just to make things easy. I will say that this is engineered very well The cable coils completely behind the mount and it hands from my outlet without any problem at all.  I expected this since I have similar for my Amazon Echo Dots .

Overall I have been very happy with the google wifi.  I switched the Xfinity wireless off and am running all my devices through the Google Wifi, it makes them very easy to manage, including port forwarding, DHCP, DHCP reservations, custom DNS and all from an easy app.  I did find that the range was good for my house (1200 sq ft.) however I did end up adding 2 more access points to extend the range for our deck and for our outdoor cameras.

Connected Garage-yes please

This one seemed like a no brainier although I am sure some would disagree.  The argument seems to be that why would you want your garage to be opened over the Internet? For me it was simple, I still needed a username and password and our garage is not connected to the house so it isn’t a home security concern. Also with the app and the xfinity integration I could have the door opening when on my motorcycle without having to stop and find the garage remote.


The setup was rather easy, add the MyQ Internet Gateway (it wants to be hardwired) and download the app.  Once downloaded you just tell it to discover and press a button the the wall panel. That’s it!  Then you can set alerts to tell you when it is open and even to close the door if it has been open for too long.  Overall this was is easy to recommend.

Starting out hub (XfinityHome)

Picking a smarthome hub is probably the biggest choice you have to make since depending on the hub you choose you may or may not be able to use the gear you have or want.  My first hub choice had more to do with our home alarm than it did with tech.  We decided to go with the Xfinity Home alarm system since we already had it for Internet and TV the price was right and it offered a good selection of “Works with Xfinity” companies

  • Lutron Caseta
  • Chamberlain MyQ Garage
  • Nest
  • August Locks
  • More to come (they claim)

First off this seems like an easy option unfortunately these are some of the higher priced options out there and the only one I have seen that actually works out of the box is the Nest. I haven’t tried the August Locks yet (I am hesitant on the cloud connected clock).  If you want the Lutron switches or blinds to work you will need a Lutron Hub (more on this one later). If you are keeping count we are at hub #2. The Nest thermostat integrated perfectly and has been solid.  The same goes for the Chamberlain Garage door opener except for that to work you need what they call their MyQ Internet Gateway and you have to have a wall panel that has the MyQ logo. We will call that a hub also so we are up to 3. 

The best let of this one was that you don’t need anything extra from Comcast, they give you a “Control Panel”

Here’s a quick look at the app as well it is very easy to use.